Black Friday is in 9 days and today you’ll learn some of the hacks our Klaviyo partner used for more than 800+ projects.

Most of them are settings that already exist in your account and are pretty easy.

Before we start, keep in mind that the impact of your optimizations depends entirely on how much traffic you're getting. If you’ve got 5,000 people hitting your abandoned checkout every month, you’ll see the results of a change pretty fast. But if it’s only 50, you’ll be waiting forever for real data, so just stick to the high-impact stuff that takes the least amount of work.

So, let’s start.

1. Determine recipients at send time

When you schedule a campaign, check "Determine recipients at send time." It's in the last step of scheduling, and it's off by default.

With it on, Klaviyo takes a fresh snapshot of your list or segment right before the email goes out. With it off, the audience is locked the moment you hit Schedule.

A lot changes in those days. You might send a bigger discount to someone who just bought with a smaller one, and that's a quick way to deal with a mountain of returns. You might also email people who no longer fit your segment's filters.

But you can't combine it with sending in each recipient's local timezone though. Klaviyo makes you pick one.

It's super easy to skip over this box, so add it to your pre-send routine.

2. Use multiple segments in one campaign to unlock Audience Breakdown

Audience Breakdown is effectively a hidden Klaviyo feature. It only appears when a campaign is sent to more than one list or segment.

Send to a single segment and you get one blended number. Send to several (engaged 30 / 60 / 90 / 120 days, split by 0, 1, 2+ orders) and you can see exactly which group opened, clicked and bought.

Here's the setup I'd use:

  • Engagement windows that don't overlap: engaged in the last 0–30, 31–60, 61–90 and 91–120 days. For example, "engaged in the last 60 days but not the last 30."

  • Order count: 0, 1, 2 and 3+ orders, all time.

Avoid overlapping segments in your BFCM campaigns. By using distinct segments (e.g., 0–30 days vs. 31–60 days), you ensure each subscriber is counted only once, keeping your data clean and your reporting accurate.

Focus on click and order metrics rather than open rates, as Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection makes open data unreliable and inflated.

That's how you learn things like who buys what and see which groups need bigger discounts to move and which loyal customers are happy with smaller offers, letting you build your future strategy on actual data.

If you’ve got a smaller list, don't try to use all 16 segments right away the data will be too thin to tell you much. You can start by segmenting just by engagement or order history first, then layer them once you’ve got enough volume to actually see what's working.

3. Turn on anonymous visitor tracking

Make sure you've got anonymous visitor tracking turned on. It lets you see what people are doing on your site even before they sign up or buy and once they do, Klaviyo automatically fills in all that past activity so you can see their full journey.

Think of a clerk in your store quietly watching a shoppe, "Visitor X walked in, checked out the jackets, tried one on, and left." They’re anonymous for now, but the second they sign up as Julia, Klaviyo automatically links that entire history to her. That's first-party data you'd otherwise throw away.

Keep in mind these 3 limitations for anonymous visitor tracking:

  • Users have to opt into cookies

  • Data only sticks around for 14 days (or 7 if they're on Safari),

  • You've got to make sure Shopify's additional tracking is actually turned on.

4. Turn Smart Sending off in every flow

Smart Sending blocks your abandonment emails if a customer got another message in the last 16 hours. Since we're sending daily campaigns during BFCM, you don't want your most important reminders getting filtered out. Turn Smart Sending off for your flows and just use flow filters instead.

Keep Smart Sending on for your regular campaigns so you don't overwhelm your subscribers.

5. Match your popup trigger to your offer

If you want to keep conversions high during BFCM, make sure your popup settings actually match your offer:

  1. Use exit-intent only for your regular campaigns

  2. Big BFCM sale, set the popup to load immediately

6. Add a popup teaser so dismissed popups can come back

Most people close the popup the second they land and some of them decide to buy few minutes later and there's no way back to your discount.

A teaser leaves a small tab on the page that reopens the form. In Klaviyo's form builder, set it to show "after form is closed." It’s an easy way to let people reopen the offer if they change their minds and decide to buy.

Note: Teasers are compatible only with popup, flyout, and full-page forms. They do not work with embedded forms.

Don't just give people an unsubscribe link as that’s the fastest way to lose them for good. People during BFCM get overwhelmed, so give them a preference instead by letting them choose to get emails weekly, monthly, or just for sales instead of saying goodbye forever.

It isn't a default setting, so you have to build it, but it only takes a few minutes.

8. Check UTM tracking on every flow email

Klaviyo's revenue only shows up correctly in GA4, Triple Whale, Northbeam or any other attribution tool, when your UTMs are right. Get them wrong and your email numbers are off, which throws off everything else.

Two places to check:

  1. Settings → Other → UTM tracking. Confirm UTM tracking is set up and "Automatically add UTM parameters to links" is on.

  2. Each flow email. Confirm "Enable UTM Tracking" is ticked. The account setting doesn't reach a flow email where that box is unticked.

9. Send your first abandoned cart email fast

Stop waiting 4 hours for your first abandoned cart email that's way too long for BFCM.

Send that first one within 20 minutes to 2 hours instead. Klaviyo's own guidance is slower which is 2 to 4 hours, and its pre-built flow waits 4. We’ve found that hitting them while they're still in "shopping mode" and actively comparing your deal to others is an easy win to get the sale.

10. Save your best offers for your highest predicted CLV

We use Klaviyo’s predictive analytics to look at order history and guess a customer's lifetime value over the next year and we use it a lot with brands that struggle to identify their VIPs.

By focusing your biggest discounts on the loyal crowd, you'll boost your ROI and make sure your best deals are going to the people most likely to keep buying from you.

For example, if your average CLV is $100, giving someone with a predicted CLV of $200 a great offer is usually a really good idea.

Keep in mind that Klaviyo’s predictive analytics appears once you’ve got enough data of at least 500+ customers who have ordered, 180 days of history, orders in the last 30 days, and some customers with 3+ orders.

If you're not seeing those features yet, just use the order-count buckets from Hack #2 as a solid workaround to find your VIPs.

11. Ruthlessly suppress unengaged profiles

Unengaged profiles cost you twice because they add to your Klaviyo bill, and they drag down your deliverability over time so clear them out before BFCM.

Here's how we do it:

  1. Build a segment of your unengaged profiles.

  2. Send them 2 breakup campaigns to try to win them back one last time.

  3. Suppress everyone who didn't engage with the breakup campaigns within 48 hours.

  4. Set up a winback flow (optional)

Again Suppress, NOT delete. Suppressed profiles don't count toward your plan, and you keep their data. Deleted data is gone for good. Klaviyo will also suggest profiles to suppress under Audience → Profiles → View suppressed profiles.

12. Make people want to open

A lot of brands still send generic subject lines and preview text from a generic brand name. Please please don't be one of them. Give people a real reason to open, and make the email feel personal.

Here's what's working for us:

  • An emoji as the first character

  • "You," "your" or "yours" in the subject line

  • A short subject line, under 7 words if possible

  • A person as the sender, like "Yiqi from Aimerce" instead of just "Aimerce"

  • The customer's name in the subject line where you can

  • A hook in the subject line, then urgency and curiosity in the preview text

None of it matters if you land in spam anyway. Make sure you’re totally set up for Gmail and Yahoo’s requirements by using a dedicated sending domain, get your DMARC configured, add one-click unsubscribe, and keep those spam complaints under 0.3%. Seriously.

13. Optimize for mobile

We have noticed that very few brands test and optimize for mobile properly. You might wanna do this as most of your subscribers read email on their phones.

Three quick fixes:

  1. Compress every image. People open email on the go, and their connection won't always be great.

  2. Split text into mobile-only and desktop-only blocks so font sizes work on both. Don't do this with images, though. The email then carries every image twice and gets heavy.

  3. Use Klaviyo's mobile preview, then send a test to your own phone before anything goes out.

We have covered everything we wish to let you know. If you have questions, feel free to send us an email. I read every one of them.

✌️Here to help you win,

Yiqi

P.S. Btw., this playbook is part of our BFCM Klaviyo & Meta Academy, a free series for DTC brands running through mid-December. New sessions drop every week.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate